Performance reviews are crucial not only to your employees’ professional development, but your organisational success too!
An effective performance review should be more than just a formal evaluation. It should be an opportunity for you to communicate openly, provide constructive feedback, and set goals. In this article, we’ll explore the best practices for conducting meaningful performance reviews, ensuring they align with best practices, and your business’s objectives.
The Purpose of Performance Reviews
A performance review serves multiple purposes, including:
- Providing employees with feedback on their performance and contributions.
- Identifying strengths and areas for improvement.
- Setting goals for future development and career growth.
- Enhancing employee engagement and motivation.
- Aligning individual performance with organisational objectives.
Your employees will expect fairness, honesty, and support in their performance evaluations. Therefore, you should approach these reviews with a focus on collaboration and development, rather than pure criticism.
Preparing for a Performance Review
Proper preparation is essential for a successful performance review. You should take the following steps:
1. Gather Relevant Data
A comprehensive evaluation should be based on measurable performance data, including:
- Key performance indicators (KPIs) relevant to the employee’s role.
- Feedback from peers, clients, and other stakeholders.
- Self-assessment forms completed by the employee.
- Records of previous performance reviews and progress on past goals.
- Productivity metrics and any documented challenges.
2. Schedule the Review in Advance
Performance reviews should never come as a surprise to your team. Employees should be informed well in advance about the review date, its purpose, and what to expect. This will give them enough time to prepare, and reflect on their own performances.
3. Set Clear Objectives
Each performance review should have clear objectives, such as recognising achievements, discussing challenges and areas for improvement, and/or planning future development. Defining these objectives in advance ensures that the review remains focused and productive.
Conducting the Performance Review
The review meeting itself should be structured, professional, and engaging. Here are some key steps to follow:
1. Create a Comfortable Environment
Your employees should feel comfortable discussing their performance. Choose a private, distraction-free setting where open and honest dialogue can take place. Building trust is key to a successful review.
2. Start with Positive Feedback
Opening the review with positivity and a recognition of achievements and strengths helps set the tone moving forward. Highlighting what the employee has done well can encourage meaningful communication and engagement.
3. Provide Constructive Feedback
When discussing areas for improvement, focus on specific examples rather than vague criticisms. Constructive feedback should be:
- Objective: Base feedback on factual evidence, rather than opinions.
- Solution-oriented: Offer suggestions on how to improve rather than just pointing out issues.
- Balanced: Ensure a mix of praise and constructive criticism.
4. Encourage Employee Participation
A performance review should be a two-way conversation – you should be discussing their performance with them, instead of at them. Encourage your employees to share their own perspectives, discuss challenges, and provide honest, critical feedback about their role and the workplace environment.
5. Set Clear Goals and Action Plans
Discussing future goals and creating an action plan is a critical part of the review. We recommend that your goals should be SMART:
- Specific: Clearly defined, and easy for the employee to understand.
- Measurable: Progress should be trackable using relevant metrics.
- Achievable: Realistic and attainable within a given timeframe.
- Relevant: Aligned with both the employee’s role, and organisational objectives.
- Timely: Set within a specific period to ensure accountability.
Following Up After the Review
A performance review should not be a one-time event, but rather part of an ongoing employee development process. After the review, you should:
- Document the discussion: Summarise key points, agreed-upon goals, and action plans in writing. Additionally, keep these organised, and on file.
- Provide support: Offer necessary training, resources, or mentorship to help employees achieve their goals. Avoid setting goals without the resources and means to achieve them!
- Schedule follow-ups: Regular check-ins ensure progress is being made, and provide opportunities for further discussion. This also promotes accountability, and will help you motivate your employees to do their best.
- Encourage continuous feedback: Performance discussions should happen regularly, not just once a year, or every few years. Giving relevant, independent feedback is also a great way to help your employees professionally develop over time.
Key Considerations
You must ensure that performance reviews comply with employment laws, and industry best practices. Key considerations include:
- Fair and unbiased assessments: Reviews must be based on objective criteria, and free from discrimination based on protected characteristics. (Human Rights Act 1993). Performance management processes should also align with terms and conditions within the employment agreement.
- Clear performance expectations: Employees should be aware of their job responsibilities, and the expected outcomes.
- Opportunity to respond: Employees should be given a chance to discuss their performance, and raise any concerns they may have.
Conclusion
Conducting an effective performance review requires careful planning, open communication, and a commitment to helping your employees develop. By focusing on constructive feedback, goal setting, and providing ongoing support, you can create a positive review process that benefits not only your employees, but your organisation too.
Need some Advice?
From developing HR strategies to creating employment agreements, policies, and managing performance systems, People Associates provides a hands-on approach that will ensure that your practices align with your business objectives, driving success.
Want a free consultation?
Flick us a message here – or contact Lisa Oakley at lisa@peopleassociates.nz or on 027 573 5483.
For more amazing tips and insights – follow us! Instagram | LinkedIn | Facebook